And those individuals will hopefully get honest reviews and their douchebaggary will be known to the world. I highly doubt many people will do this unless they don't care about their reputation, networking, etc.. And besides if they do develop a certain public reputation then no one will want to sit next to them.
I think this idea is absolutely brilliant. It makes me even want to travel more. I love meeting people and have different interests I'd be happy to talk about for hours and hours with someone. You'll either learn new things, make contacts, or be teaching someone whereby you're strengthening your own understanding. It's win-win-win!
Very cool idea. The only problem is making sure that the interest is reciprocal. Instead of being able to see where others may be seating, it should show all people on board and allow you to express interest, which then gives the other person the ability to reciprocate. If the other person declines, the declination should be in ambiguous terms so the person declining neither offends or feels obligated, such as "This person has declined because they plan to rest or do work while on this flight"
I bet people could use this to break into houses. Given the right person with lax privacy settings. One public facebook event with your address or something and someone who knows you'll be flying.
If you have no control over who might sit next you you I agree. However imagine if you were flying NYC-SF and could find out who were entrepreneurs, software engineers or designers on you flight and talk shop for a couple of hours.
The key issue is discovering if the interest is mutual. It's not unsolvable. Merely intractable.
personally I agree with you - I would probably be scanning that list for someone who doesn't want to talk, isn't fat and doesn't have a golfball bladder.
However, a friend of mine would probably love this. He's constantly traveling for work and always looking for people to talk to (in his industry/sphere of interests) because it's so boring. There's plenty of travelling salesmen types out there who want this, so why not let them sit together :)
Several young, socially connected folks give it a shot.
Horny dudes browse the passenger list looking for a "hot chick" to sit next to.
Girls wise up to what the guys are doing and stop signing up.
Guys do what we always do and lose interest in yet another "social activity" completely devoid of women.